| Four killed
in crash |
| |
|
|
|
| The Irish Times, Friday, July 2,
1999 |
|
|
24-hour helicopter
rescue service for
southeast |
|
|
|
| By Lorna
Siggins, Marine Correspondent
The Government has met its commitment to providing a
24hour helicopter search and rescue service for the south-east coast, with the
relocation of an Air Corps Dauphin to Waterford airport.
The Dauphin replaces the existing Alouette
helicopter, which was stationed at Waterford a year ago as part of improved
search and rescue cover, but was limited to daylight hours only. The provision
"marks the final step" in establishing a "second-to-none air-sea helicopter
emergency infrastructure" on this coast, the Minister for the Marine and
Natural Resources, Dr Woods, said yesterday.
The Irish Marine Emergency Service (IMES), run by Dr
Woods's Department, has two medium-lift Sikorsky S-61N helicopters based at
Dublin and Shannon airports, on contract from the Scottish company, Bond
Helicopters, at a cost of £4.5 million annually. An Air Corps Dauphin is
based at Finner camp in Co Donegal. The upgrade at Waterford means that "world
class" rescue helicopter coverage is now available 24 hours a day around this
coastline, at a time of increased maritime activity, Dr Woods said.
The Minister also paid tribute yesterday to
the Dublin-based Sikorsky S-61 N, which flew 103 missions in its first year and
saved or assisted 46 people. The Price Waterhouse report on the review of the
Naval Service and Air Corps has recommended that the Air Corps be equipped with
four medium-lift helicopters over a four-year period, and replacement of the
existing helicopter fleet of 15 Dauphin and Alouette craft with eight
Squirreltype helicopters. This would allow the Air Corps to bid for the State's
search and rescue service when the contract on the west coast comes up for
renewal.
To date, however, there has been no
significant movement on the Minister for Defence's proposed implementation plan
for the report. |
| RTE News On-Line, Friday, July 2, 1999,
9.37am |
|
|
|
Four killed in Air Corps helicopter
crash |
The Dauphin helicopter arriving for service
yesterday |
Rescue services
at the scene |
|
|
An Air Corps helicopter has crashed in dense fog in
County Waterford resulting in the deaths of its four man crew. The Dauphin
helicopter burst into flames after it crashed down into a large sand dune at
Tramore beach. The crew members, who were in their late twenties or early
thirties, have been named as Captain Dave OFlaherty from Lucan in Dublin;
Captain Michael Baker from Wexford; Sergeant Paddy Mooney from Meath; and
Corporal Niall Byrne from Dublin.
The four were returning from a successful rescue
mission but crashed having aborted three attempted landings at Waterford
airport due to the foggy conditions. The Dauphin helicopter only began
operating from County Waterford yesterday, in order to give the region a 24
hour rescue service. It had replaced the Alouette which can only fly during
daylight hours.Air crash investigators from the Department of Defence and the
Army are at the scene. This is the first crash of an air corps helicopter in
active service in the history of the state.
President Mary McAleese and the Taoiseach, Bertie
Ahern, have led the messages of sympathy to the families of the four Air Corp
personnel. The Taoiseach said he is deeply shocked by the tragedy. In a
statement, Mr Ahern said that the untimely death of the four men was all the
more poignant given that they themselves had helped to save the lives of people
on a vessel in distress a short time before the crash. |
| The Irish Times, Friday, July 2, 1999
[Breaking News - On-Line] |
|
|
|
Wreckage found in search for army
helicopter |
|
|
|
| 10.15 a.m. A search for a missing Army helicopter
and its four-man crew has discovered burnt-out wreckage early today. The Army
was unable to confirm casualties at the scene of the accident at Tramore, Co
Waterford.
But the wreckage, discovered after sightings
of a "fireball" at 2.35 a.m., was confirmed as that of the missing aircraft,
Dauphin, by a spokesman.
It was returning from a rescue mission when
contact was lost after a communication at 12.37 a.m.
The crew of four in the Defence Forces Air
Corps had earlier made three attempts to land at Waterford Airport, and was
prevented from doing so by dense fog.
In their last contact they indicated that they
would attempt to land near Tramore beach.
Defence Minister Mr Michael Smith and Minister
for the Marine Mr Michael Woods were travelling to the crash site at
Tramore.
Earlier the helicopter crew had helped rescue
five people in a small boat reported missing off the coast late last
night.
They had been summoned from their base in
Waterford shortly before midnight to join two lifeboats searching for the boat
which was subsequently found. The boat was towed to safety by the Helvic
Lifeboat and those on board were unharmed.
However the alarm was raised for the
helicopter crew itself shortly after contact was lost and the wreckage was
found by rescuers searching the beaches and cliffs.
An air and sea search was immediately launched
when radio contact was lost, said an Army spokesman.
It involved two lifeboats, the Emer nautical
vessel, the Irish marine services helicopter based at Dublin, coastal units and
police, he said. At 2.28 a.m. today, searchers sighted the burning wreckage of
the helicopter on the beach at Tramore.
"The search for bodies was being concentrated
in that particular area," added Defence Forces spokesman Commandant Eoghan
O'Neachtain. "While every effort is being made to locate the crew the
possibility of finding survivors is remote," he said.
The Army later named the men on board the
helicopter as Captain Dave O'Flaherty, 30, from Tullamore, Co Offaly; Captain
Mick Baker, 28, from Enniscorthy, Co Wexford; Sergeant Paddy Mooney, 34, from
Stamullin, Co Meath; and Corporal Niall Byrne, 24, from Killiney, Co
Dublin.
The Taoiseach Mr Ahern said he was deeply
shocked by the tragedy.
In a statement issued from Belfast, where he
is taking part in the bid for Ulster peace, he said: "Their untimely deaths is
all the more poignant given that they themselves had helped to save the lives
on board the vessel only a short time beforehand.
"Our sympathy is with their families, who we
hope will take some solace from the bravery and selfless commitment to duty
displayed by their loved ones. They can be very proud of them, as we all
are." |
| The Examiner, July 3,
1999 |
|
|
United in grief at beach where four young men lost their
lives |
|
|
|
by
Marion OMara
THE stench of scorched metal and charred foam amid
mounds of ash told its own tragic story of how four crew members of the Air
Corps Dauphin helicopter died on the sand dunes just feet away from Tramore Bay
yesterday morning. Captain Dave OFlaherty (30), a married man
from Lucan, Dublin; Captain Mick Baker (28), single from Castleknock, Dublin;
Sergeant Pat Mooney, a father of three from Stamullen, Co. Meath, and Corporal
Niall Byrne (24), single from Killiney, Dublin, died instantly when their
helicopter crash landed and burst into flames in the sand dunes separating
Tramores main beach from the back strand. The wreckage was spread over 40
yards. All that remained of a helicopter only put into service on
Thursday was an emergency exit door, part of the nose of the craft, a blue
seat, two pieces of foam seat padding and a collection of maps embedded in the
grass covering the soft sand. Grieving families visited the crash
site at lunchtime yesterday, just two miles from Tramores promenade.
Its a popular walking area for locals and tourists. But
yesterday an air of gloom hung over the area as dense as the fog which played a
part in the tragedy. Comdt. Gerry Hannon who escorted people to the
crash site was a personal friend of the men who died. Only 12 hours
earlier he joined them in launching the new 24 hour search and rescue service
in the south east. Yesterday members of the defence forces place
floral wreaths on a small sandy hill overlooking the site. The
Dauphin was the first helicopter to crash while on active service in the Air
Corps 77 year history. Most of those who gathered offered
silent prayers as they tried to come to terms with the tragedy. As
the painstaking job of sifting through each blade of grass began, Comdt. Hannon
said he had no way of knowing what happened during the Dauphins the final
moments. Asked if the pilot may have believed he was already on the
beach he replied: I honestly dont know. It is hard to
know. He paid tribute to fire brigade personnel, the
gardaí and all the emergency services whom he said did a fantastic
job. The whole area was cordoned off while each piece of
the wreckage was gathered and tagged to be taken by low loader to Baldonnel for
an intensive investigation, he said. |
| The Irish Times, Monday, July 5,
1999 |
|
|
Smith pledges to restore rescue service to
Waterford |
|
|
|
| By
Chris Dooley, South East Correspondent
A 24-hour search-and-rescue service with a
replacement Dauphin helicopter will be restored to Waterford, the Minister for
Defence has promised.
Mr Smith said it would be a tribute to the men
who were killed in Friday's crash to continue the service.
The four died in the first nighttime operation from
Waterford regional airport. The Dauphin they were flying had been relocated to
Waterford from Baldonnel on Thursday, to give the south-east coast a 24-hour
rescue service.
The aircraft replaced an Alouette helicopter
which had been stationed in Waterford a year ago as part of improved
search-and-rescue cover, but was capable of daytime flying only. A Defence
Forces spokesman, Capt Tom Clonan, said the lost Dauphin would be replaced by
an Alouette while the operational situation at Waterford was being reviewed.
But while no official announcement has been
made, Mr Smith told The Irish Times that another Dauphin would be stationed in
Waterford to bring about a resumption of the 24-hour service, which the
Government and the Defence Forces had been committed to providing for some
time.
Whatever had to be done to make this come
about would be done, he said, whether it involved purchasing a new helicopter
for the area or relocating a Dauphin from elsewhere in the State.
It is likely to be months, however, before the
night-time service can be restored. Mr Smith pointed out that it was not simply
a matter of replacing the lost aircraft; there was also a considerable
investment to be made in producing crews of the calibre and experience of the
men who were killed on Friday.
The helicopter's pilots, Capt Dave O'Flaherty
(30), from Tullamore, Co Offaly, and Capt Mick Baker (28), from Enniscorthy, Co
Wexford, were both qualified flight instructors with more than 20 years'
service in the Air Corps between them.
While the crash investigation proceeds, the Defence
Forces' other Dauphin helicopters will remain in service, Capt Clonan
said. |
| The Irish times, Monday, July 5,
1999 |
|
|
|
Hundreds attend O'Flaherty
funeral |
|
|
|
|
Hundreds of people gathered in Tullamore, Co Offaly,
yesterday for the funeral of Capt David O'Flaherty, one of the four Air Corps
members who died in Friday's helicopter crash in Co Waterford.
Air Corps colleagues formed a guard-of-honour
outside Clon minch cemetery as the funeral cortege arrived, preceded by the
Band of the Defence Forces Training Centre at the Curragh.
The coffin, draped in the Tricolour, was borne
on a gun carriage.
The attendance included many representatives
of the Army, Naval Service, Irish Marine Emergency Service, the British Coast
Guard, the Fire Brigade and Ambulance Services, the Garda
Síoch´ana and the Organisation of Ex-Servicemen and Women.
Capt O'Flaherty's body was buried beside that
of his father, Frank, who died 22 years ago.
Prayers at the graveside were led by Father
Brendan Madden, Air Corps chaplain, who was assisted by a local curate, Father
Oliver Skelly.
The local Church of Ireland clergyman, Canon
Alistair Grimason, gave a reading.
After the burial, three Marchetti Air Corps
planes flew over the cemetery as a tribute. They were flown by a crew from the
pilot training school, where Capt O'Flaherty had trained as a flying
instructor.
The band sounded the Last Post, while a volley
of shots was fired by Air Corps members. A piper, Airman Joe O'Donnell, sounded
a lament.
The chief mourners were Capt O'Flaherty's
wife, Maria; mother, Lily; brother, Dermot, and sister, Valerie. |
| The Irish Times, Monday, July 5,
1999 |
|
|
|
Guard of honour as bodies
leave airport |
|
|
|
By Chris Dooley, in Tramore In a simple, dignified ceremony, the bodies of the four Air
Corps men killed in Tramore on Friday were carried across the tarmac at
Waterford regional airport on Saturday before making their final journey to
Baldonnel.
The bodies had remained overnight at Waterford
Regional Hospital, where a short service was conducted by two Army chaplains,
Father Michael Murphy and Father Dick Marnell, both of the Southern
Command.
It was from here the men had taken off on Thursday
night for what should have been a routine search-and-rescue operation. But,
with the mission successfully completed, dense fog prevented them from landing
at the airport on their return, forcing them into the illfated attempt to land
at Tramore beach, 4 km away.
In a ceremony conducted with full military
honours, the coffins were conveyed past a guard of honour which included many
of those, marine rescue personnel and members of local mountain rescue teams -
who had taken part in the search for the missing helicopter on Friday
morning.
The guard of honour also included the Minister
for Defence, Mr Smith; Brig Gen Dave Taylor, general officer commanding
Southern Command; and the Ministers of State, Mr Martin Cullen and Mr Hugh
Byrne. The small group of relatives present included Mr Tony and Mrs Mary Baker
from Enniscorthy, Co Wexford, whose son, Capt Mick Baker (28), died in the
crash. |
| Irish Independent, July 5,
1999 |
|
|
|
Chopper manufacturer joins
disaster investigation team |
|
|
|
| By
RALPH RIEGEL and MICHAEL QUINN
EXPERTS from French aircraft manufacturer,
Aerospatiale, are to assist an Air Corps probe into the helicopter crash in
Tramore, Co Waterford on Friday that killed four men returning from an heroic
rescue mission in dense fog.
The move came as Air Corps personnel and politicians
slated as ``insensitive and disgusting'' a newspaper report which claimed the
flying record of the helicopter's pilot, Captain Dave O'Flaherty (32) was now a
focus of the probe.
The Sunday Times claimed that the service record of
the Offaly-born pilot who was buried yesterday in his native Tullamore after a
ceremony at Baldonnel was now being examined as part of the crash
investigation.
But Air Corps officers reacted with fury to any
implication that the pilot may have been responsible for the crash and to the
publication of such a report on the very day the Captain was buried.
"To describe this as in poor taste is very much an
understatement,'' Cork TD Billy Kelleher declared. "I think the very suggestion
and its timing is not only insensitive but cruel and disgusting,'' he
declared.
Air Corps officers who are leading the crash probe
with a team from the Department of Public Enterprise's Accident & Emergency
Unit are furious at ongoing speculation over the crash cause.
Investigators have already ruled out claims the
high-tech Dauphin helicopter ran out of fuel and have vehemently insisted that
there is no evidence to date to explain the crash and explosion.
Fragments of the 13-year-old French chopper were
meticulously collected over the weekend and removed from the Saleens crash
site, one mile outside Tramore.
The fragments will now be carefully examined by
forensic analysts to try and piece together the last moments of the
twin-engined chopper.
Unlike civil aircraft, the Air Corps chopper did not
have a digital data recorder, the so-called `black box' which could explain why
the Dauphin struck the sand dune.
The chopper's manufacturers, Aerospatiale, which is
now a part of the Eurocopter consortium, is to provide detailed assistance to
the investigation.
Nicknamed the `Plastic Puppy', the Dauphin is
regarded as the world's finest short-range Search And Rescue (SAR) helicopters
and is in service with the US Coast Guard and the China's Air Force.
However, the Dauphin has been the focus of a number
of crashes over recent years, most notably in Asia.
A total of seven fatal crashes have involved the
Dauphin over the past decade; in Japan (three, in 1987, 1990 and 1991), India
(two, in 1988 and 1989), Norway (in 1996) and the Philippines (on 1989).
At least three crashes involved adverse weather
conditions.
Visibility off the Waterford coast at the time of
the 12.30am crash last Friday was said to be down to little more than 25
feet. |
| The Irish Times, Monday, July 5,
1999 |
|
|
|
Islands mourn loss of four airmen |
|
|
|
| 'All we islanders depend for our safety and security on the
selfless dedication of the men and women who provide our rescue services.
Because of their total professionalism, commitment and willingness to respond
in impossible weather conditions, it has never been safer to live
here.
"Without them, our survival as island
communities would be threatened. My heart goes out today to the wives,
children, parents and families of these brave men who have made the ultimate
sacrifice to save others. Our thoughts and prayers are with them in their
grief."
These are the words of Dr Marion Broderick,
Aran Islands lifeboat medical officer and GP, who is one of many to convey
sympathy to the Air Corps on the loss of four airmen in Co Waterford on
Friday.
Up in the north-west, where a special award
ceremony for Irish Marine Emergency Service (IMES) personnel set for last
Friday was deferred, there are people who remember the heroism of one of the
men who died.
Capt David O'Flaherty had tested the limits of
the Dauphin helicopter in an extraordinary rescue in February 1998. The
Shannon-based IMES Sikorsky had answered a call-out to lift an injured
fisherman from a Norwegian vessel off Co Mayo in 50knot winds with a 20ft
swell. However, the Sikorsky's equipment failed and it had to abandon the
task.
The Air Corps Dauphin, based at Finner, Co
Donegal, was called out. Along with Comdt Seán Murphy, Airman John
O'Rourke and Airman Jim O'Neill, Capt O'Flaherty escorted the Sikorsky to
Blacksod, Co Mayo. The Dauphin refuelled and flew back to airlift the injured
man and an IMES winchman left behind from the Sikorsky.
The Dauphin then took the injured man to Sligo
hospital and had barely touched down when it received a request to pick up a
sick man on Inishbiggle, Co Mayo, and bring him to Castlebar. |
| Irish Independent, July 6,
1999 |
|
|
|
Sky-high tribute to Niall
the hero |
|
|
|
Vincent Byrne comforts his daughter Aoife during
the burial of his son Cpl
Niall Byrne |
|
|
|
| By
MIRIAM LORD
IT was a beautiful summer afternoon in a grassy
place between the mountains and the sea. Quiet and peaceful. A lovely lazy day
for watching jet planes draw white vapour trails across the sky.
The rifle fire was fading on the warm air of
Shanganagh cemetery, and the bugler was still playing The Last Post when three
planes roared in from beyond the Wicklow mountains and flew in traditional
salute past the funeral party.
To the uninitiated, it was a fitting and impressive
tribute to a dead hero. But the ranks of airmen saying goodbye to their brave
colleague could read the other message in the sky.
Because the three Marchetti aircraft were flying
overhead in Missing Man Formation.
Twenty-four-year old Corporal Niall Byrne from
Killiney was the youngest man to die in last week's Air Corps helicopter
tragedy. Yesterday, the brave winchman who routinely risked his life to save
others, was laid to rest with full military honours in a south county Dublin
graveyard.
But for all the soul-stirring brass band and sombre
marching ceremony of the military funeral, this was still the story of one
family's tragedy.
On a sun-drenched morning in Killiney, Niall's
mother Anna and his fiancée Teresa Molloy held onto each other for
support as they walked past the blue uniforms and the green and the navy into
the Church of Our Lady of Good Counsel. Teresa clutched Niall's red Manchester
United jersey and his sky blue Dubs jersey they would be presented as offertory
gifts along with his cherished Air Corps safety certificate.
Corporal Byrne's father Vincent shielded his
distraught daughter Aoife (15) as they made their way inside, followed by her
older brothers Eunan, Donal and Ronan. They listened as Father Frank Monks
talked about their Niall, and how everyone was looking forward to his impending
marriage to Teresa, and how he was going to be the priest at his wedding.
``Thursday night, Friday morning shattered that
dream.''
Hundreds of people came their honour Niall's memory
and pay their respects to his devastated family. Included among the mourners
who had met this exceptional young man was President Mary McAleese, who had met
Niall when he was on a tour of duty in the Lebanon a number of years ago and
still remembered him.
Comrades from the Air Corps in their distinctive
blue uniforms fought to hold back the tears as the service progressed. By the
time they got to the graveyard, with the evocative strains of the Last Post
playing and the silver arrowhead of planes speeding overhead, many had given in
to their emotions.
The men and women who fly the resue missions are
part of a special family of people. Ambulance crews, mountain rescue teams,
certain members of the Garda Siochana, Garda divers, lifeboat men and women,
firemen they are selfless and courageous individuals who rely on each other so
others in difficulties can depend on them.
They were all in mourning yesterday. Maybe, too,
somewhere in the crowd, were people who had been plucked to safety by winchman
Byrne.
On the final journey uphill to the graveyard, the
Army Number One band slow-marched to a lament in front of the remains. The
tricolour-draped coffin had been on gleaming brass gun carriage and, on the
coffin, rested Cpl. Byrne's blue Air Corps cap and a single red rose.
The sombre procession passed through a 32-strong
guard of honour which lined the approach road. On command, they reversed arms
and bowed their heads. Niall's family walked behind the gun carriage, each one
of them carrying a single, long-stemmed, red rose.
At the graveside, the flag was removed and carefully
folded. After prayers, a firing party of seven fired three perfectly timed
volleys. Soldiers and airmen saluted when the Last Post played, looking up and
in to the sun as the three planes flew by and out to sea. Even for the military
men, it was hard not to cry.
Airman Francis Whelan, an Air Corps piper, played
Amazing Grace. Teresa Molloy's engagement ring glinted in the sunshine, her
shaking hand clutching a handkerchief and a rose. She stood close to Niall's
mother Anna, and then both women stepped forward and cast the roses into the
open grave. Teresa held onto the blue silk rose Air Corps colours.
Together, the family stood in reflection. Saying
goodbye to Niall, son, brother, fiancé. And hero. |
| The Examiner, July 6,
1999 |
|
|
|
Helicopter manufacturers to assist inquiry
|
|
|
|
by
Barry OHalloran THE
manufacturers of the helicopter which crashed last week killing four airmen
will take part in the Aer Corps appointed inquiry into the tragedy, the Defence
Forces confirmed last night.
An Aer Corps court of inquiry has been set up to
lead the probe into Fridays accident in Tramore, Co Waterford in which
the air sea rescue fliers lost their lives after delivering the crew of a
fishing boat to safety. The court, which will have its own technical
staff, will oversee the gathering of any relevant information and will liaise
with anyone who can shed light on any aspect of the tragedy. The
Dauphin helicopters French manufacturer, Eurocopter ö formerly
Aerospatiale ö is expected to aid the investigation. A Department of
Defence spokesman said last night that the company has already been
contacted. They will be interested in this themselves, and
would normally make contact in these circumstances, he said. Their
advice will have to be sought by the inquiry. He explained that the
investigators will also have to re assemble the aircraft as far as is
practicable. The court of inquiry is a formal body, set up
under statute, but it will not function like a normal court. A Defence Forces
spokesman explained that it will simply be charged with establishing how the
accident happened. It is an inquiry, nobody will be accused of
anything and there wont be questioning and cross examining witnesses. It
will have a technical board appointed by the Aer Corps and its job is to find
out what happened, this is done in any case like this, he said. It is not
known when the investigation will be completed. Aerospatiale designed
the Dauphin which is a twin engined craft with a top speed of 170 miles an hour
and can travel for 530 miles without refuelling. They are used in a
number of countries, including Ireland and Britain, for air/sea
rescue. |
| The Examiner, July 7,
1999 |
|
|
|
Enniscorthy honours helicopter captain
|
|
|
|
| by Billy Quirke
THOUSANDS assembled at St Aidans Cathedral,
and joined the funeral cortege on its route to St Marys Cemetery, as
Enniscorthy interred its latest soldier hero, 28 year old Captain Michael Baker
of Carleys Bridge Captain Baker was the last to be buried of
the Air Corps Dauphin helicopter rescue team who lost their lives at Tramore
last Friday. Her excellency President Mary McAleese was in attendance
and the Government was represented by Minister for the Marine Dr Michael Woods
and Minister for Defence Michael Smith TD. Most Rev. Dr Brendan
Comiskey , Bishop of Ferns was chief concelebrant at Requiem Mass and the
congregation included leaders and members of all denominations. State
departments and services, and a group from the Royal Air Force also paid their
respects in the cathedral where Captain Michael and his siblings Tom, Cormac
and Antoinette were christened and confirmed, and where their mother Mary is
the long serving organist. Mary, her husband Tony, and their three
surviving children followed immediately behind the traditional gun carriage,
flanked by an Air Corps Guard of Honour as business in the town shut down and
roads were closed to traffic. The coffin was draped in the National flag with
the young officers blue Air Corps cap on top. Every section of
the community of Co. Wexford joined in a poignant goodbye to a brave young
man. But grief was permeated with shame amongst the general populace.
The disgusting act of burglary against the bereaved family as they attended the
National Prayer Services in Baldonnnel last Saturday could not be set
aside. Gardaí in Enniscorthy are confident of making an
arrest, however. Two engagement rings and two watches were stolen
from the home of Capt. Bakers parents, Tony and Mary, at Carleys
Bridge outside Enniscorthy in the raid. Superintendent Pat Delaney
said their enquiries into the burglary are continuing, but progress is being
made. The Bakers are a very well known family and there is a
deep sense of revulsion at this crime. We have received a description of a
person seen in the area around the time of the burglary, and we hope that an
arrest will be made soon, Supt Delaney said. He ruled out the
likelihood that the burglary was planned in the knowledge that the family were
away at their sons removal. At this stage we believe it
was purely a coincidence that the Baker home was targeted. |
| Irish Independent, July 7,
1999 |
|
|
|
Tragedy strikes a chord in
nation's psyche |
|
|
|
A
sister's grief . . . Capt Mick Baker's sister Antoinette wipes
away a tear
as he was laid to rest in Enniscorthy yesterday
|
|
|
|
| By
MICHAEL QUINN
THE deaths of the four Air Corps crewmen in the
Tramore helicopter disaster touched a chord in the psyche of the nation,
mourners were told at the funeral of Captain Mick Baker yesterday.
The head chaplain to the Armed Forces, Monsignor
John Crowley, said the tragedy had touched the hearts of countless people over
the last five days.
President McAleese lead the mourning when leaders of
church and State gathered with local people in St Aidan's Cathedral,
Enniscorthy, Co Wexford. The Government was represented by the Minister for
Defence Michael Smith, Dr Michael Woods, Minister of the Marine, and
Wexford-based Junior Minister Hugh Byrne.
The town came to a standstill when the
tricolour-draped coffin was drawn through the streets on a gun carriage to its
resting place in St Mary's cemetery.
People were stunned by the sudden deaths said Fr
Crowley. The hearts of all went out to his parents, Tony and Mary, and his
brothers Tom and Cormac and sister Antoinette, he said.
It was difficult to make sense of why the tragedy
happened.
"It is against nature for parents to bury their
child. When we bury our parents we close the door on the past but when parents
bury a child it closes the bridge to the future,'' he said.
Sympathy was also expressed to Capt Baker's
girlfriend, Siobhan Dunne of Clonroche, Co Wexford.
And Fr Crowley condemned the burglary of Capt
Baker's family home in Enniscorthy while the family attended the removal of his
remains in Baldonnel.
"Not only did his parents lose their son, but
somebody tried to exploit the tragedy.''
During the offertory procession, symbols of Capt
Baker's life were taken to the altar. A flying helmet recalled his role as a
search and rescue pilot and a model yacht symbolised his recent passion for
sailing.
A hurley and two jerseys of the Wexford Raparees and
Dublin-based Commercials symbolised his love of sport. There was also a trumpet
and a book of poems as well as strawberries symbolising his family's long
association with fruit growing in the county.
The poem Flying High was recited during Mass in
which Capt Baker's cousin, Archdeacon John Hogan, was a concelebrant. Bishop
Brendan Comiskey gave the final commendation.
Colleagues of the dead airman formed a guard of
honour at the cemetery and a firing party discharged a volley as the coffin was
lowered into the ground. A bugler played The Last Post and there was a fly-over
of three Air Corps jets in the `lost man' formation. |
| Irish Independent, July 7,
1999 |
|
|
|
Hundreds in sad farewell to helicopter crash
hero |
|
|
|
Sad
farewell . . . Sgt Patrick Mooney's eight-year-old son
Conor, wearing his father's Air Corps cap, carries a single red
rose at the
funeral in Stamullen, Co Meath yesterday |
|
|
|
| By
ELAINE KEOGH
MORE than 500 mourners attended the moving funeral
service yesterday of helicopter crash victim Sergeant Patrick Mooney.
In a poignant homily during the service in
Stamullen, Co Meath, the Air Corps Chaplain, Father Brendan Madden, referred to
Sgt Mooney's work with the Search and Rescue Support Unit.
He said that many children still had fathers and
many fathers still had children because of his actions.
The village was a sea of green and blue as the
34-year-old's colleagues in the Defence Forces came to pay their last respects
to the popular and respected father of three, who was one of four victims of
the helicopter crash in Tramore, Co Waterford, last Friday.
St Patrick's Church was too small to hold the crowds
who came to pay their respects to the Air Corps sergeant and many stood in
silence in the car park outside.
Sgt Mooney's ten-year-old daughter, Aisling, read a
prayer she wrote herself.
She said she would never forget her father.
Fr Madden said the airman's widow, Monica, believed
one day he would reach down and lift her up to join him in heaven.
The flying jacket he wore on each of the search and
rescue operations was brought up during the offertory procession along with his
green Irish Rangers Unit beret, his UN beret and two GAA jerseys from the local
St Patrick's and Balscadden Blues clubs.
His brother, Joe, told the congregation that
Balscadden Blues club was retiring the No 6 jersey Patrick had worn as a mark
of respect.
The mourners were led by President Mary McAleese,
the Minister for Defence, Michael Smith, and the Minister for Social, Community
and Family Affairs, Dermot Ahern.
The pallbearers included his brother, Joe, and his
cousin, PJ Cudden, who are also members of the Defence Forces.
The Last Post was played as his tricolour-draped
coffin was led to nearby Stamullen cemetery.
Sgt Mooney's widow was comforted by his mother,
Miriam, and her aunt, Kathleen Gilligan.
His eight-year-old son, Conor, walked at the front
of the cortege wearing his father's Air Corps cap and carrying a red
rose.
As part of the military funeral, six volleys of
three shots were discharged over the coffin and three Marchetti aircraft flew
overhead.
The planes normally fly in a cross formed by four
aircraft; the missing plane yesterday was to mark the loss to the Air Corps of
the sergeant.
The Defence Forces were represented by Chief of
Staff Lieutenant-General David Stapleton; General Officer Commanding Air Corps,
Brigadier-General Patrick Cranfield; and Commander Noel Goulding representing
the Naval Service. |
| The Irish Times, Wednesday, July 7,
1999 |
|
|
|
Airman's rescue heroism recalled at funeral
Mass |
|
|
|
Conor Mooney (8), son of Sgt Patrick Mooney, walks at the front of
the cortege. |
|
|
|
By Elaine
Keogh
More than 500 mourners attended the funeral in
Stamullen, Co Meath, yesterday of Sgt Patrick Mooney. In a poignant and moving
homily, the Air Corps chaplain, Father Brendan Madden, referred to Sgt Mooney's
work with the Search and Rescue Support Unit.
He said: "Many children have fathers and many
fathers have children because of Patrick".
The village was a sea of green and blue as his
colleagues in the Defence Forces came to pay their last respects.
The small church of St Patrick was far too
small to hold the crowd, and many stood in silence in the car-park
outside.
Sgt Mooney's 10-year-old daughter, Aisling,
read a prayer she wrote herself and said she would never forget him.
Father Madden said his widow believed that one
day he would reach down and lift her up to join him in heaven.
The flying jacket he wore on each of his
search-and-rescue operations was brought up during the Offertory procession,
along with his green Irish Rangers Unit beret, his UN beret and two GAA jerseys
from the local St Patrick's and Balscadden Blues clubs.
His brother, Joe, told the congregation that
Balscadden Blues club, as a mark of respect, was retiring the No 6 jersey which
Patrick had worn.
Mourners included the President, Mrs McAleese,
the Minister for Defence, Mr Smith, and the Minister for Social, Community and
Family Affairs, Mr Dermot Ahern.
The pallbearers included his brother, Joe
(Dave), and his cousin, Mr P.J. Cudden, who are also members of the Defence
Forces.
The Last Post was played as his
Tricolour-draped coffin was led to nearby Stamullen Cemetery.
Sgt Mooney's widow was comforted by his
mother, Miriam, and her aunt, Ms Kathleen Gilligan. His eight-year-old son,
Conor, walked at the front of the cortege wearing his father's Air Corps cap
and carrying a rose.
As part of the military funeral, six volleys
of three shots were discharged over the coffin and, because the sergeant was a
member of the Air Corps, three Marchetti jets flew overhead. The jets normally
fly in a cross formed by four aircraft; the missing plane yesterday was to mark
the loss to the Air Corps of the sergeant.
The Defence Forces were represented by the
Chief-of-Staff, Lieut Gen Dave Stapleton; General Officer Commanding the Air
Corps, Brig Gen Pat Cranfield; and Commander Noel Goulding, representing the
Naval Service. |
| The Irish Times, Wednesday, July 7,
1999 |
|
|
|
Mourners told of young man 'taken in an
instant' |
|
|
|
Thousands turned out yesterday on the
streets of Enniscorthy, Co
Wexford, as the remains of Capt Mick Baker were taken from
St Aidan's Cathedral after his funeral
Mass. |
|
|
|
| By
Chris Dooley, in Enniscorthy
The final act of the Air Corps crew killed in
Friday's crash was one of compassion, mercy and a concern for those who were
vulnerable, the funeral of the last of the four men to be buried was told
yesterday.
Mgr John Crowley, head chaplain of the Defence
Forces, told mourners at the funeral of Capt Mick Baker in Enniscorthy, Co
Wexford, that he was a young man "full of energy, enthusiasm and zest for life
taken from us in an instant".
"We seek and search for something to hold on
to at this time. It must be our belief and our hope that God does not inflict
such tragedies on us. They come unbidden, unwanted from our world."
Several hundred mourners lined the street
outside St Aidan's Cathedral, which was packed for the funeral Mass.
The chief mourners were Capt Baker's parents,
Tony and Mary, sister Antoinette, brothers Cormac and Tom, and girlfriend
Siobhan Dunne.
Mr and Mrs Baker had previously lost another
son, John, aged three, in 1980.
The President, Mrs McAleese, attended
yesterday's funeral, while the Taoiseach, Mr Ahern, was represented by his
aide-decamp, Capt Michael Kiernan.
Also present were the Minister for Defence, Mr
Smith; the Minister of State for Marine and Natural Resources, Mr Hugh Byrne;
the Chief-of-Staff of the Defence Forces, Lieut Gen Dave Stapleton; and the
General Officer Commanding the Air Corps, Brig Gen Pat Cranfield.
In a homily, Mgr Crowley, who was chief
concelebrant, said sudden and unexpected deaths shattered our world.
"One minute we are talking about the regular
things of life, and within seconds all is changed, and changed for ever. On
Thursday last our lives were focused on the future, of dreams and hopes to be
realised. Friday morning, it was about the past and memories of happier days
and happier times."
He said no words of his could adequately
encapsulate the emptiness, pain and sorrow felt by Capt Baker's loved
ones.
Referring to the robbery which took place at
Capt Baker's parents' home on Saturday night, Mgr Crowley said that not only
had they lost their son, "but others chose to exploit this tragedy for their
benefit".
"What can I say? What can anyone say? But as I
look down this church today, I see so many people, your friends, and friends of
Mick, neighbours, representatives of church and State, good people, kind
people, loving people.
"The support and concern of others sustain us
all at such times. Love will overcome and win out, even over death."
There were frequent references to Capt Baker's
avid interest in poetry, which he frequently quoted to his Air Corps
colleagues. Mgr Crowley read lines from "one of Mick's favourite poems", which
he often quoted, The Listeners, by Walter de la Mare.
"The death of his brother, John, had
challenged Mick to face difficult and painful issues, and perhaps gave him that
tremendous zest for life, and living it, his sense of fun, and 110 per cent
commitment to sport, to sailing, to flying and to life itself."
The Bishop of Ferns, Dr Brendan Comiskey, led
the final commendation, after which Capt Baker was buried with full military
honours at St Mary's Cemetery. |
| Irish Independent, July 28,
1999 |
|
|
|
Crash killed four crewmen
instantly |
|
|
|
Lt
Col Martin Egan and Sister Mary Bonefield of the Medical
Corps at the
inquest in Waterford yesterday |
|
|
|
| By
MICHAEL QUINN
THE four Irish Air Corps crewmen of the Dauphin
helicopter which crashed in Tramore sand dunes were killed instantly, inquests
heard yesterday.
Verdicts were returned that the men, Capt Dave
O'Flaherty (30), married, a native of Tullamore, Co Offaly; Capt Mick Baker
(28), single, of Enniscorthy, Co Wexford; Sgt Paddy Mooney (34), married, a
native of Stamullen, Co Meath and Cpl Niall Byrne (24), single, of Killiney, Co
Dublin, died of multiple severe and traumatic injuries consistent with an air
crash.
The disaster took place in thick fog on July 2 last
within hours of the helicopter taking up new round the clock duties and guiding
a successful rescue mission.
The four bodies received third degree burns and
charring and identity was established by their dental records. Pathologist Dr
Joseph O'Connor, Waterford, said the bodies received multiple compound
fractures and vital organs were ruptured in the crash.
The coroner for east Waterford, Frank Hutchinson,
solicitor, said the inquests would not be closed until the investigation into
the tragic accident was completed and he adjourned the matters for one year. Mr
Hutchinson said he had not come across an inquest like this which evoked such
genuine sadness. The mission on which the men were involved drew sympathy from
the people of Ireland and without them many more people would have died in the
Waterford area.
"I want to thank you publicly for making that
possible and for making these men available to us,'' he told the victims'
families.
"I hope in time to come you will experience feelings
of consolation. It was a privilege to have them serve here and their memories
will be cherished for a very long time.''
Sgt Robert Murphy, Air Corps helicopter wing, said
he saw the ill-fated helicopter departing at 22.40pm on July 1.
The next sighting of the craft was in the Tramore
sandhills. Garda Simon Murphy, Waterford, said he searched the sand hills for
the overdue helicopter and found burning wreckage spread over a wide area at
4am.
There was thick fog which limited visibility to 10
to 15 yards. Garda Sgt Chris Delaney, Waterford, then located the four bodies
and placed them in body bags. A spokesman for the Air Corps thanked the people
of Waterford and Tramore for their sympathy, help and understanding.
The search and rescue unit based at Waterford
Airport is still operating and fulfilling the ideals of the Air Corps, the
inquest heard. |
| The Irish Times, Wednesday, July 28,
1999 |
|
|
|
Air Corps men suffered
multiple injuries inquest |
|
|
|
| By
Chris Dooley, in Waterford
The four Air Corps men killed in the helicopter
crash in Tramore earlier this month died from multiple severe traumatic
injuries, the inquests into their deaths heard yesterday.
Their relatives were told in Waterford that
the tragedy had touched the public in a unique way. The families were also
thanked by the coroner for east Waterford, Mr Frank Hutchinson, for the
life-saving services the men had provided.
Dental records were used to identify the
bodies of the men, who all died instantly when their Dauphin helicopter crashed
into a sand dune at Tramore Burrow on July 2nd, as they were attempting to
return from a successful searchand-rescue mission.
The four were Capt Dave O'Flaherty (30), who
was married with no children, from Tullamore, Co Offaly; Capt Mick Baker (28),
single, from Enniscorthy, Co Wexford; Sgt Paddy Mooney (34), married with three
children, from Stamullen, Co Meath; and Cpl Niall Byrne (24), single, from
Killiney, Co Dublin.
Having heard evidence as to the immediate
cause of death, Mr Hutchinson adjourned the inquests for a year, pending the
outcome of the official investigation into the cause of the crash.
In evidence, Garda Simon Murphy said he
arrived at the scene of the crash on the sand dunes at Tramore beach at about 4
a.m. The wreckage of the helicopter was still burning, and parts were thrown
across a wide area. Fog was thick and visibility was down to 10 to 15 yards.
Members of the Tramore unit of the Irish Marine Emergency Service and two Air
Corps personnel were already present.
Sgt Chris Delaney said he arrived at 4.10 a.m.
and secured the scene with Garda Murphy.
He was present when the four bodies were
recovered and placed in body bags. He accompanied them to the mortuary at
Waterford Regional Hospital.
Two South Eastern Health Board dental
surgeons, Dr Maeve Keller and Dr Maura Haran, later identified the bodies using
dental records supplied by the Defence Forces' medical unit.
Dr Joseph O'Connor, who carried out the
post-mortems, said an external examination of all four showed severe traumatic
injuries, with third-degree burns and charring. The men suffered multiple
fractures and internal injuries. The doctor agreed with Mr Hutchinson that
death in each case was instantaneous.
Mr Hutchinson told family members that he had
never come across "such genuine sadness and heartfelt feeling as I've found in
the last few weeks".
Death in each case, he said, was due to
multiple severe traumatic injuries consistent with an aviation
accident. |
| The Irish Times, Monday, August 16,
1999 |
|
|
|
Experts aid helicopter crash inquiry |
|
|
|
| By
Chris Dooley, South East Correspondent
Experts from Sweden and Britain have been called in
to assist in the investigation into last month's helicopter crash in Tramore,
which killed four members of the Air Corps.
It will be several months at least before the
investigation team is able to produce a draft report on the cause of the
accident, the worst in the Air Corps's 77-year history.
Interested parties including members of the
victims' families will be invited to comment on the initial findings before the
final report is published.
The investigation is the first of its kind in
that it is headed by a member of the Air Corps, Lieut Col Tom Moloney, but is
being conducted under civil regulations with the involvement of the air
accident investigation unit of the Department of Public Enterprise.
One of those brought in to assist in the
inquiry is a "human factors" expert, Ms Kristina Pollock, who is director of
military safety in Sweden and has been involved in over 100 air accident
investigations.
She will provide a report on aspects such as
the kind of pressure the helicopter's pilots were working under and the
decision-making process involved.
The investigators will not, however, seek to
apportion blame for the crash.
Mr Kevin Humphreys, who heads the air accident
investigation unit at the Department of Public Enterprise, said the purpose was
to find out what happened "and hopefully learn whatever lessons are needed to
ensure it doesn't happen again."
The second foreign expert employed, Mr Richard
Whidborne, is a principal inspector at the UK's air accident investigation
branch in Farnborough. He is a helicopter specialist and will also provide a
report for the investigation team.
Further specialist analysis will be carried
out in France, under the supervision of Lieut Col Moloney and his team, by the
manufacturers of the Dauphin helicopter and its engine.
Capt Dave O'Flaherty (30), from Tullamore, Co
Offaly; Capt Mick Baker (28), Enniscorthy, Co Wexford; Sgt Paddy Mooney (34),
Stamullen, Co Meath; and Cpl Niall Byrne (24), Killiney, Co Dublin, all died
instantly when their helicopter crashed into a sand dune near Tramore beach in
Co Waterford.
They were returning from a successful
search-and-rescue mission off the south-east coast but dense fog had prevented
them from landing the helicopter at their base at Waterford Regional
Airport. |
| The Irish Times, October 2,
1999 |
|
|
|
Tricolour-covered coffins of
'four of our finest' |
|
|
|
The remains of
the four airmen who died when their helicopter crashed at Tramore are blessed on arrival at
Casement Aerodrome, Baldonnel, Co Dublin, on Saturday evening.
|
|
|
|
| By
Roddy O'Sullivan
Their coffins lay in Hangar 3 in Baldonnel on
Saturday in the same configuration as the men had sat on their last flight two
nights before. Pilots Capt Dave O'Flaherty and Capt Michael Baker were to the
front, winchmen Sgt Paddy Mooney and Cpl Niall Byrne behind.
Draped in Tricolours, the caskets were
surrounded by hundreds of floral tributes, their colour a sharp contrast to the
concrete grey and military green of the hangar. Along the white section of two
of the Tricolours lay the swords which Capt Baker and Capt O'Flaherty received
with their officers' commissions.
"Four of our finest, our most experienced, our
most professional" were taken, the congregation was told. Four men who had been
"so vibrant, so energetic, so full of life" were gone.
The CASA aircraft carrying the men's remains had
taxied on the runway at Casement aerodrome at 7 p.m. The coffins were taken
from the back of the plane one by one, while relatives and colleagues watched
from the edge of the runway. A lone piper played Raglan Road, as four groups of
the men's colleagues took it in turn to remove the coffins.
The President, Mrs McAleese, led the mourners with
the Taoiseach, Mr Ahern, who had been flown to the talks in Stormont earlier in
the week by two of the men. Joining them were the Tánaiste, Ms Harney,
the Minister for Defence, Mr Smith, and the Minister for the Marine, Dr
Woods.
Also present was the Auxiliary Bishop of
Dublin, the Most Rev Raymond Field. Leading the military mourners was the
Chief-of-Staff of the Defence Forces, Lieut Gen David Stapleton, and his Deputy
Chiefs-of-Staff, Brig Gen Mangan and Brig Gen O'Dwyer. They were accompanied by
the Officers Commanding the Air Corps and Naval Service, Brig Gen Patrick
Cranfield and Commodore John Kavanagh. The American and British military
attachés and a search-and-rescue team from RAF Chivenor also joined with
the mourners.
The family and friends of Cpl Niall Byrne
gathered for a prayer service in Baldonnel last night. His burial will take
place this morning in Shanganagh Cemetery after 11 a.m. Mass at Our Lady of
Good Counsel Church, Johnstown, Killiney.
Sgt Paddy Mooney's remains were kept at his
family home in Stamullen, Co Meath, last night and will be removed for 7 p.m.
Mass tonight. He will be buried tomorrow in Stamullen after noon Mass. Capt
Michael Baker's remains will arrive at St Aidan's Cathedral, Enniscorthy, Co
Wexford, at 6 p.m. today. He will be buried tomorrow at St Mary's cemetery
after 4 p.m. Mass. |
|
|